Neighbors’ Complaints Force Beloved Cafe to Close
Emma Ayles Shuts Down The Caddy Shack Cafe
In a surprising turn of events, Emma Ayles, a 47-year-old cafe owner, had to close her beloved cafe due to complaints from three neighbors. The main issues were the smell of bacon and the noise of clinking teacups. This unfortunate closure has left eight people unemployed and Emma devastated, especially since it happened just before Christmas.

A Community Hub Shuttered
The Caddy Shack Cafe, located in Dorset and set up with the Weymouth and Portland Rugby Club, opened in April 2022. Emma converted a metal shipping container into a cozy cafe on the rugby club’s land while seeking permanent planning permission. The cafe quickly became a local favorite, attracting walkers, school children, and disabled individuals on mobility scooters. It served as a gathering place that fostered a sense of community.

Complaints and Council Rejection
In October 2022, three nearby residents complained about the “noise and odor” from the cafe. These complaints led Dorset Council to reject Emma’s planning permission application in February. Despite her appeal, the decision stood, forcing Emma to close her business.

Emma’s Struggle and Disbelief
Emma expressed her frustration, sharing how stressful it had been to battle against the potential closure week after week. She had to break the devastating news to her employees just before Christmas. Emma expressed her disbelief, saying, “Nobody understands why they have closed us down. Everyone is flabbergasted.”

Ridiculous Objections and Community Impact
The complaints pointed out the “smell of bacon” and the sounds of “teaspoons and teacups” as sources of disturbance. Emma found these objections ridiculous, noting that the prevailing wind typically carried any bacon scent away from the complainants’ homes. She humorously asked, “What do they want us to do, use chocolate teacups so there is no sound?”

Emma also criticized the council’s decision, highlighting the negative impact on her loyal customers, especially the students from Wyvern School and disabled individuals who found the cafe accessible. She stated, “I just feel bad for the community as groups met at the cafe every day.”

Rugby Club and Public Outcry
The Weymouth and Portland Rugby Club, disappointed with the judgment’s consequences for both players and the local community, appealed the planning decision. They acknowledged the challenges faced by small businesses in the current economic climate and expressed gratitude to the cafe’s loyal customers for their support.

Social Media Backlash
This closure has caused outrage on social media, with many expressing disbelief at the complaints and subsequent actions. Individuals like Kati Eastwood sarcastically commented on the complaints, while Jon Fells lamented the closure and praised the cafe.

Balancing Local Business and Resident Concerns
This controversial incident raises important questions about balancing support for local businesses and addressing residents’ concerns. It remains to be seen if further actions will address the situation or if there will be a reevaluation of the decision to close The Caddy Shack Cafe.